Paper: Estonian oil shale resources calculated by GIS method

http://www.minest.ee/mining txt: Oil Shale, 2003, Vol. 20, No. 3 SPECIAL ISSN 0208-189X pp. 404-411 © 2003 Estonian Academy Publishers ESTONIAN OIL SHALE RESOURCES CALCULATED BY GIS METHOD I. VALGMA* Department of Mining, Tallinn Technical University 82 Kopli St., Tallinn, 10412 Estonia http://www.ttu.ee/maeinst/ A digital map of Estonian oil shale mining was created for joining the data about technological, environmental, and social limitations in the deposit. For evaluating potential resource of oil shale, based on borehole database, its amount, tonnage and energy were calculated. Thereafter the quantity of economical oil shale for power plants and shale oil resource were calculated. Energy rating is the most important factor for determining oil shale reserves in the case of using it for electricity generation. In the case of oil production, data on oil yield and potential resources in oil shale are the most important figures to determine the value of the deposit. Basing on the models, oil resource has been calculated. Resource data can be used for composing master plans for the deposit considering both power generation and oil production. The data can be also used for composing development plans of mines and for logistics calculations. Introduction Oil shale bed in Estonia is deposited in the depth of 0–100 m with the thickness of 1.4–3.2 m in the area of 2,884 km2 (Fig. 1). The mineable seam consists of seven kukersite layers and four to six limestone interlayers. The layers are named A–F1. The energy rating of the bed is 15–45 GJ/m2 . Oil shale mining in then Estonia Province started in 1916; it was extracted in surface mines using the opencast method. Underground mining started in 1922. Room-and-pillar mining, which is the only underground oil shale mining method today, was started in 1960. During the years 1971– 2001 in some mines longwall mining with shearers was used. In total ten oil shale surface mines and thirteen underground mines have been in operation. Probability of opening new operations is high if oil shale processing or cement productions become more active. * Estonian Oil Shale Resources Calculated by GIS Method 405 Estonia Russia Lake Peipus Mined out area Exploration fields Gulf of Finland outcrop 25 50 kilometres 0 Jõgeva county Järva county Lääne-Viru county Ida Viru county Jõhvi Kohtla-Järve 0 4 Kiviõli Kunda M t Narva Narva-Jõesuu Rakvere Sillamäe Tapa Fig. 1. Baltic oil shale area The Criteria of the Oil Shale Reserve The criteria of the oil shale reserve are: energy rating, calorific value of the layers, thickness and depth of the seam, location, available mining technology, world price of competitive fuel and its transporting cost, oil shale mining and transporting cost. In addition, nature protection areas are limiting factors for mining. The economic criterion for determining Estonia’s kukersite∗ oil shale reserve for electricity generation is the energy rating of the seam in GJ/m2 . It is calculated as the sum of the products of thickness, calorific values and densities of all oil shale layers A–F1 and limestone interlayers. A reserve is mineable when energy rating of the block is at least ∗ In addition to kukersite oil shale in Estonia, there are occurrences of another kind of oil shale – Dictyonema argillite, mined and used in Sillamäe for extracting uranium in 1948–1953. Table 1. Estonian Oil Shale Reserves, M tons, January 1, 2002 Range of mineability Economic Subeconomic Cut-off-grade – energy rating of bed, GJ/m2 Reserves 35 25 Range of exploration: Measured & indicated 1,186 1,760 Indicated & inferred 302 1,751 Total 1,488 3,511 Including: Operating mining fields: Measured 513 150 Inferred 172 36 Abandoned mining fields: Measured 17 73 Inferred 5 7 406 I. Valgma 35 GJ/m2 , and subeconomic if energy rating is 25–35 GJ/m2 . According to the Balance of Estonian Natural Resources, the oil shale reserve was 5 billion tonnes in the year 2002. Economic reserve was 1.5 billion t and subeconomic – 3.5 billion t (Table 1). These numbers apply to oil shale usage for electricity generation in power plants and are calculated only by oil shale layers, which is fiction because in most cases the total bed is used for combustion. In the case of wide-scale using of oil shale for cement or oil production, the criteria must be changed. The presented official reserve data are not reliable as seen in Fig. 2. Reliability is only 50 % on the lines of 35 and 25 GJ/m2 , as well as in any other point on the deposit. As well known in practice, the reliability is sufficient beginning with 70–85 %. In fact about 35 % from the reserve of the Estonia mining field are below economic level. Fig. 2. 0.85 0.7 0.5 0.7 0.85 35 GJ/sq m 25 GJ/sq m Permisküla Narva Aidu Viru Estonia Ojamaa Uus Kiviõli Puhatu Tudu Peipsi Ahtme Oandu Sonda Seli Fig. 2. Reliability of reserves Oil shale resource depends on the consumption amount. The graph in Fig. 3 shows the age of oil shale resources if resource is calculated by criteria proceeding from electricity generation. If the output level is ten million tonnes per year, the economic reserve in mining fields of operating mines will last for 25 years. In the case of technological development and changing environmental limitations, this period could prolong to 45 years. When accounting all economic reserve, the period of mining will last 60 years with 10 Mt production. The following conclusions could be made after evaluating the age of resources: • Economic reserve will last until the year 2025 • The reserve must be recalculated using new criteria in the case of widescale oil production Estonian Oil Shale Resources Calculated by GIS Method 407 0 20 40 60 80 100 5 10 15 20 25 30 Oil Shale Output, mill. tonnes per year Resource age in years Economic, Measured & Indicated reserve Economic, Measured & Indicated reserve plus half of marginally economic Economic reserve of operating mines Total reserve of operating mines Fig. 3. Age of oil shale resources Modeling Basing on geological data, several grids of oil shale layers and seams were created (height, thickness, in-place tonnage, energy rating, overburden thickness and stripping coefficient). Oil Shale Resource For evaluating potential resource of oil shale, its amount, tonnage and energy must be calculated. Then the quantity of economical oil shale for both electricity and oil production is calculated. Assuming that Estonia deposit is a combination of current exploration fields, the polygon shown in Fig. 4 marks the deposit area covering 2,884 km2 . The quantity of the oil shale seam could be calculated by extracting seam thickness and corresponding areas from the created isopachs using SQL query. Inverse distance weighting (IDW), triangulation with smoothing, natural neighbour, rectangular interpolation and Kriging methods could be used for interpolation. IDW Interpolation can be used because the errors of the initial data exceed smoothing level of the method. Smoothed isopleths give a more clear overview of the deposit and allow to extrapolate the data beyond the data points. Calculating and interpolating energy rating per square meter are necessary for energy resource evaluation. The graph based on the model (Fig. 4) shows the energy ranges of oil shale of the deposit, the quantity already mined out and the available resource. Most of the mined-out seam has had the energy rating value over 35 GJ/m2 (Fig. 5). Energy rating of the seam is an essential argument for economical calculations. 408 I. Valgma 10x10km 43 41 39 37 31 27 25 35 33 29 21 23 45 43 25 45 47 27 33 37 39 41 Fig. 4. Energy rating of oil shale, GJ/m2 . The resource over 35 GJ/m2 is oil shale economic reserve. Bold contours in north mark the mined-out area 0 1000 2000 3000 4000 5000 6000 7000 8000 9000 10000 Energy rating of oil shale, GJ/m2 Oil shale resource, PJ (1015J) Mined out PJ 0 0 0 0 37 0 7 382 1465 1219 2790 4570 6451 362 Unmined PJ 570 9923 9340 7939 7150 6628 6844 6886 5704 5097 4047 3630 768 0 21 23 25 27 29 31 33 35 37 39 41 43 45 47 Fig. 5. Oil shale resource of the Estonia deposit in PJ. Most of the mined-out seam has had energy rating over 35 GJ/m2 The models enable to present the graphs of energy rating showing its extent and ranges. Energy rating is the most important factor for determining oil shale reserve in the case of using it for electricity generation. In the case of oil production, the most important figures are oil yield and its resource. Basing on the models, oil resource has been calculated and is presented in Fig. 6. Estonian Oil Shale Resources Calculated by GIS Method 409 Fig. 6. Shale oil resource, million tonnes, in ranges of oil yield Choosing between various interpolation methods showed that IDW gives the most reliable figures for oil shale tonnage with average figures of the reserve blocks. Natural Neighbour regions and Kriging are the more suitable interpolation methods when using more detailed data and blocks. Rectangular Interpolation is unsuitable in the case of irregular mesh of the initial data. All methods give 2.3 m for oil shale seam average thickness except rectangular interpolation that gives 2.1 m and 11 % deviation. Other methods give deviation from 1 to 3 %, which are smaller than errors of the initial data. Calculated Data of the Deposit The main results of the calculations are data models of the deposit such as isopleths and 3D drawings of mining conditions like seam thickness, seam depth, calorific value of oil shale and oil yield. The main possible calculations basing on oil shale bedding models are: choosing optimum mining location, dynamics and statistics of the mining phenomenon, evaluation of oil shale quantity, energy and oil reserve. IDW method gives satisfactory data for the deposit overview (Table 2), other suitable methods can be used for modeling with all initial drill hole data in the case of resource calculations for some specific location. One of the preliminary results of the modeling is obtaining cost data. Reinsalu has applied his methodology and study to the current deposit model and shown the cost of oil shale tonne over the deposit. The cost is 100 kroons per tonne in the center of Estonia mining field (Fig. 7). Oil cost in situ is 100 % for cost of the tonne in the centre of Estonia mining field and according to Fig. 8 can be applied to other parts of the deposit. 0 50 100 150 200 250 Oil yield, t/m 2 Oil resource, Mt Mined out Mt 0 0 1 0 2 24 34 85 151 14 Unmined Mt 140 247 187 170 173 156 127 94 48 0 0.4 0.45 0.5 0.55 0.6 0.65 0.7 0.75 0.8 0.85 410 I. Valgma Table 2. Data of Estonia Oil Shale Deposit Calculated with IDW Method Parameter Unmined % Mined-out % Total or average Area, km2 2476 86 409 14 2,884 Oil shale tonnage, Mt 10,139 84 1,900 16 12,039 In-place tonnage, t/m2 4.1 98 4.6 111 4.2 Specific weight, t/m3 1.8 101 1.7 96 1.8 Quantity, Mm3 5,657 84 1,116 16 6,774 Energy, PJ 74,524 81 17,283 19 91,808 Energy rating, GJ/m3 30 95 42 133 32 Oil resource, Mt 1,342 81 311 19 1,652 Oil yield per m2 , t/m2 0.54 95 0.76 133 0.57 Oil yield, t/t 0.13 96 0.16 119 0.14 170 105 165 155 135 145 125 115 95 0 Puhatu Narva Uus Kiviõli Tudu 35 GJ/m2 Permisküla Peipsi 25 GJ/m2 Ida-Virumaa Harjumaa Järvamaa Lääne-Virumaa Jõgevamaa Estonia Ahtme Viru Oandu Ojamaa Sonda Seli Aidu Fig. 7. Oil shale cost, Estonian kroons 43 48 52 18 23 33 28 38 48 43 Uus Kiviõli 0 Tudu Peipsi Puhatu Narva 35 GJ/m2 Permisküla 25 GJ/m2 Ida-Virumaa Harjumaa Järvamaa Lääne-Virumaa Jõgevamaa 14 Estonia Ahtme Viru Oandu Ojamaa Sonda Seli Aidu Fig. 8. Shale oil cost, USD/barrel Estonian Oil Shale Resources Calculated by GIS Method 411 Conclusions Modeling with GIS methods together with geostatistical analysis is an effective and promising method for re-evaluating the resources of Estonian oil shale as well as of any other flat-laying deposit. Modeling with available digital geographic and technogenic data gives the possibility to analyze the resource at any level of details. Ascknowledgements This study is supported by EstSF Grant No. 4870 Oil Shale Resource. REFERENCES 1. Reinsalu, E. Criteria and size of Estonian oil shale reserves // Oil Shale. 1998. Vol. 15, No. 2. P. 111–133. 2. Kattai, V., Saadre, T., Savitski, L. Eesti põlevkivi (Estonian Oil Shale). – Tallinn, 2000 [in Estonian, summary in English and in Russian]. 3. Kattai, V. Eesti kukersiitpõlevkivi ressurss (Estonian kukersite oil shale resource) // Konverents Põlevkivi talutav kaevandamine (Proc. Conference Sustainable oil shale mining), May 2000, Tallinn-Jõhvi [in Estonian]. 4. Reinsalu, E. Is Estonian oil shale beneficial in the future? // Oil Shale. 1998. Vol. 15, No. 2. P. 97–101. 5. Valgma, I. Geographical Information System for Oil Shale Mining – MGIS : Thesis on mining engineering. http://www.ttu.ee/maeinst/mgis; Tallinn Technical University. 2002 6. Valgma, I. Map of oil shale mining history in Estonia // Proc. II. 5th Mining History Congress, Greece, Milos Conference Center, George Eliopoulos. 2001. P. 198–193. 7. Valgma, I. Mapping potential areas of ground subsidence in Estonian underground oil shale mining district // Proc. 2nd Intern. Conf. “Environment. Technology. Resources”. Rezekne, Latvia, 25–27 June 1999. P. 227–232. 8. Valgma, I. Post-stripping processes and the landscape of mined areas in Estonian oil shale open-casts // Oil Shale. 2000. Vol. 17, No. 2. P. 201–212. 9. Valgma, I. Using MapInfo Professional and Vertical Mapper for mapping Estonian oil shale deposit and analysing technological limit of overburden thickness // Proc. Intern. Conf. on GIS for Earth Science Applications / Inst. for Geology, Geotechnics and Geophysics, Slovenia, Ljubljana, 17–21 May 1998. P. 187–194. References and additional information on Estonian oil shale can be found at: http://www.ttu.ee/maeinst/mgis

Viimased blogipostitused